Debunking Used Car Buying Myths: Fact vs. Fiction at Speedway Subaru

Subaru showroom with used cars displayed.

Debunking Used Car Buying Myths: Fact vs. Fiction at Speedway Subaru

Purchasing a used car is a smart choice for many drivers, especially those near Indianapolis, IN, seeking quality and value. However, the used car market often carries misconceptions that can confuse or deter potential buyers from making confident decisions. At Speedway Subaru, located at 1930 W 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, we’re committed to transparent, honest guidance to help you separate fact from fiction when shopping for a used vehicle. Call us anytime at (317) 263-0002 to start a conversation about your next car.

Our family-owned dealership values building lasting relationships with customers from Indianapolis and surrounding communities like Danville and Meridian Hills/Williams Creek. With our expert team, extensive certified pre-owned inventory, and the SpeedwayCares Lifetime Warranty included on qualifying vehicles, we ensure your used car experience is both reliable and rewarding.

Table of Contents

Common Myths About Buying Used Cars

Many potential buyers hesitate to consider used cars due to persistent myths that may not reflect reality. At Speedway Subaru, we want to clear the confusion so you can confidently explore our extensive Used Vehicles inventory.

Myth 1: Used Cars Are Always Unreliable
This is one of the most common concerns. However, reliability depends largely on how a vehicle was maintained rather than its age alone. Modern vehicles, especially those well cared for and inspected rigorously, often outperform expectations. For example, used Subaru models equipped with symmetrical all-wheel drive and proven Boxer engines maintain excellent reliability records. Regular maintenance, such as timely oil changes and brake inspections at our service center, ensures longevity. Our dealership encourages customers from communities like Pittsboro and Greenfield to take advantage of our Schedule Service option to keep their vehicles in top condition.

Myth 2: Used Cars Are More Expensive to Insure
Insurance costs are influenced by multiple factors, including the vehicle's value, safety ratings, and repair costs. Typically, used cars cost less to insure because their market value is lower than new cars, reducing potential claim amounts. Additionally, Subaru’s strong safety features, such as EyeSight Driver Assist Technology, contribute to lower insurance premiums than many competitors in similar categories.

Myth 3: Used Cars Have Hidden Problems
While caution is wise, many used vehicles come with warranties and thorough inspections. Our certified pre-owned vehicles undergo multi-point inspections, ensuring any issues are addressed before sale. Beyond that, buyers can request a third-party mechanical inspection for extra assurance. We recommend using the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS), a government-backed database to verify history and prevent fraud. Learn more about verifying accident history in the Verifying Accident Histories section.

Myth 4: Financing Used Cars Is Difficult
At Speedway Subaru, financing a used vehicle is straightforward. Our finance experts offer tailored solutions for a variety of credit situations, including first-time buyers. We provide transparent information and competitive rates with flexible terms, making it easier for customers in neighborhoods like Meridian Hills/Williams Creek to find financial plans that fit their needs.

Pricing Myths in Used Car Purchases

Understanding pricing misconceptions can empower you to make smarter buying decisions near Indianapolis and its suburbs.

Myth 1: Used Cars Have No Resale Value
Contrary to this belief, many used cars retain significant value over time, especially if well-maintained. The primary depreciation hit occurs during a vehicle’s first few years, meaning a used car’s price often stabilizes afterward. For instance, Subaru’s models like the Outback and Forester consistently rank highly for resale value in consumer reports, making them sound investments.

Myth 2: Used Cars Are Less Fuel-Efficient
While older models might lag behind in fuel economy, many recent used cars, including hybrids and efficient engines, perform well. For example, the Subaru Forester Hybrid offers excellent mileage without sacrificing performance. Fuel efficiency also depends on driving habits and maintenance, so a well-kept used car can be nearly as economical as a new one.

Myth 3: Extended Warranties Are Necessary for All Used Cars
Extended warranties can be beneficial but are not always essential. If you purchase a certified pre-owned car from Speedway Subaru, it typically includes warranty coverage like the SpeedwayCares Lifetime Powertrain Warranty, which protects you from costly repairs for the engine, transmission, and drivetrain. This coverage reduces the need for additional warranties.

Myth 4: You’ll Always Find the Best Price Online
Online listings are valuable, but local dealerships like Speedway Subaru often have exclusive access to vehicles and special pricing. Our deep connections within the industry allow us to offer competitive deals and personalized service beyond what online platforms can provide.

Are Used Cars Truly Unreliable?

The reputation of used cars for unreliability is outdated, especially with modern manufacturing and maintenance standards. Vehicles today are built to last longer, and routine maintenance plays a critical role in their performance.

Factors Affecting Used Car Reliability

  • Maintenance history: Cars regularly serviced with quality parts, such as genuine Subaru components available through our Parts Department, generally have fewer problems.
  • Vehicle age and mileage: Many used cars with moderate mileage still have years of dependable service left.
  • Certified pre-owned status: These vehicles come inspected, repaired, and backed by warranties, offering peace of mind.

For example, drivers in Danville have reported long-lasting satisfaction with used Subaru Crosstreks and Legacy models purchased at Speedway Subaru.

Verifying Accident Histories for Peace of Mind

Protecting yourself from vehicles with undisclosed damage is crucial. The National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS) is a government-backed resource that collects data from state titling agencies, insurance carriers, and salvage yards to provide reliable vehicle histories.

Using NMVTIS and Other Reports

  • Obtain a vehicle history report from trusted providers that source NMVTIS data.
  • Look for signs of past accidents, flood damage, or title branding like salvage or rebuilt status.
  • Confirm if repairs were professionally completed and documented.

At Speedway Subaru, we provide transparent histories for all our used cars and encourage buyers to review these details before making a decision.

Why Certified Pre-Owned Cars Might Be the Better Choice

Certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicles at Speedway Subaru go beyond standard used cars in quality assurance.

Benefits of CPO Vehicles

  • Undergo comprehensive multi-point inspections covering mechanical, safety, and cosmetic components.
  • Include extended warranty coverage, such as the SpeedwayCares Lifetime Powertrain Warranty.
  • Receive roadside assistance and other perks enhancing ownership peace of mind.

Choosing a CPO Subaru near Greenfield means you gain confidence in your purchase backed by our dealership’s commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

Hidden Costs to Watch for When Buying Used

Understanding all costs involved with a used car purchase helps prevent surprises after the sale. Beyond the sticker price, consider:

  • Maintenance and Repairs: Scheduled service like brake replacements, oil changes, and tires can add up. Our Subaru Service Specials help manage these expenses.
  • Insurance: Rates vary based on vehicle type and driver profile.
  • Taxes and Fees: Title transfer, registration, and local taxes apply.
  • Fuel Costs: Fuel efficiency varies by model and driving habits.

Planning for these factors ensures a more accurate budget and a better ownership experience.

How to Negotiate the Best Price on Used Cars in Indianapolis

Getting the right price on a used car requires preparation and understanding of local market trends.

Key Negotiation Tips

  • Research comparable vehicles, like those in our Used Vehicles inventory.
  • Consider vehicle condition, mileage, and history reports.
  • Use knowledge of local demand, such as preferences in Brownsburg or Plainfield, to gauge pricing flexibility.
  • Don’t hesitate to discuss pricing transparently with our sales team, who prioritize fairness and your satisfaction.

Our experienced staff at 1930 W 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202 is ready to guide you through every step, ensuring you leave with confidence.

Finding Trusted Used Car Dealerships Near You

Choosing a dealership is as important as choosing the vehicle. Speedway Subaru’s community-focused approach, recognized by awards such as the Subaru Dealer of the Year by Cars.com and DealerRater, means you receive honest, personalized service.

Why Choose Speedway Subaru?

  • Family-owned with a personal touch, treating customers like family.
  • Comprehensive warranty programs like SpeedwayCares for long-term peace of mind.
  • A knowledgeable and friendly team dedicated to clear communication and transparency.
  • Convenient online tools to sell your trade with our Sell/Trade program or browse new Subaru models in our New Subaru Vehicles inventory.

Located centrally in Indianapolis, our dealership serves nearby communities such as Rocky Ripple and Danville, ensuring you receive the best support no matter where you live.

By addressing common concerns and myths with clear, detailed information, we empower you to make confident choices when purchasing a used car. Whether you are exploring our certified pre-owned lineup, browsing our used cars, or scheduling a maintenance visit, Speedway Subaru is here to assist you with honesty and care.

Explore our inventory or reach out to our team today by calling (317) 263-0002 or visiting us at 1930 W 16th St, Indianapolis, IN 46202.

© 2026 Speedway Subaru

Vehicle Information


Contact Information

By submitting your information, you agree to our Privacy Policy.


By providing the information on the form above, including phone number, and clicking submit, I consent to receive email messages and texts from Speedway Cars regarding the services they offer. I understand that my consent is not required to purchase services. Please note, you will be provided an opportunity to opt out of text messaging with any text message you receive.

Dealership Information